Greetings, Card Floppaz!
Last October I did a little mini Magic: The Gathering tournament with the few Commander decks I owned, but ran out of steam when The Hobbit set came out and I realized that I kinda hated the Commander format.
Soooo, instead I cobbled together a whopping eighteen 60-card decks and I'm here to see how they bounce off each other.
Here they are:
1) Aura of Courage - Voltron Deck
2) Draconic Rage - Tiamat Dragon Horde
3) Dungeons of Death - Complete a Ton of Dungeons
4) Planar Portal - Treasure / Cast from Exile
5) Lae-zel's Legions - Counters and Healing
6) Critcal Hit! - Optimized Dice Rolling
7) Drizzt's Token Swarm - Generates tokens
8) Food and Fellowship - Hobbits and their Snacks
9) Elven Council - Galadriel and Lothlorien
10) The Hosts of Mordor - Sauron's Army
11) Return of the King - Aragorn, Gondor and Rohan
12) Fury of Orthanc - Saruman and the Uruk Hai
13) Forest Critters - Beorn and Radagast's Creature Horde
14) Middle Earth Monsters - Spiders, Wolves and Trolls
15) Goblin Town - Goblin Horde with a splash of Smaug
16) "We're Going On An Adventure" - The Dwarves and Bilbo complete Sagas, which (in theory) are manipulated by Tom Bombadil and Goldberry
17) Dwarves - Thorin and Company Piss Off a Dragon.
18) Alliance of Elves and Men - Laketown, Bard and Thranduil's Elves
Keep in mind: these decks are built entirely with theme in mind, not effectiveness. As such, any notable synergies are either intrinsic to the card type or a shared mechanic.
I'll determine match ups randomly with a 20-sider. This being an elimination-style tourney, eventually we're gonna have some random "byes", but we'll cross that bridge when we get to it.
***
ROUND ONE
Ready? Here we go..."7" versus "15."
"Drizzt's Token Swarm" vs. "Goblin Town"
Drizz't goes first, starts with seven cards, but no draw. Plays a "Citadel Gate", picks Black as the alternate color.
The Goblins start with seven cards and draw at the start of their turn. Plays a Swamp and passes.
Drizz't draws, plays a Forest but sadly must pass.
The Goblins play a Mountain and then they pass.
Drizz't draws and, without a Land draw, must pass.
The Goblins play a Mountain and table "Rage into the Valley", Amassing a 2/2 Goblin Army, losing one Life and drawing a card. Pass.
Drizz't drops a Forest and plays "Jaheira, Friend of the Forest." Passes.
The Goblins flop a Mountain and then play "Gundabad Opportunist" for all four Mana. Holds and ends turn.
For three Mana, Drizz't plays "Carefree Swinemaster" and ends their turn.
The Goblins play "Goblin-town" ('natch) then cast the Exiled card ("Goblin Plate Mail") courtesy of the Opportunist. It attaches to the Goblin Army, now boosted to 4/3 with Menace. They then cast "Crude Bent Blade" for three Mana, and - with that - Drizz't is forced to sacrifice the Swinemaster. Both the Army and the Opportunist then Attack. Jaheira blocks the Opportunist and they both die and Drizz't goes down to 16 Life. End of turn.
Drizz't plays a Forest and then casts "Ochre Jelly" with four Mana, making it a 3/3. Ends turn.
Goblins drop a Swamp then table "Stony-Voiced Goblins" (Drizz't discards "The Book of Vile Darkness"!) and "Front Porch Sentries." They then pay two Mana to Equip the Stony Gobz with the Crude Bent Blade. Attacks with the Menacing Goblin Army, putting Drizz't down to 12 Life.
Drizz't plays a second "Ochre Jelly" with four Mana, making it a 3/3. Ends turn.
Goblins play another Swamp and with seven Mana drop a "Stone-Giant of High Pass", which - in turn - creates a "Stone Boulder." The Goblin Army and the Stony Goblins both attack! Both Jellies block the Army, killing it along with one Jelly. The dead Jelly then returns at the beginning of the End Step as a 1/1 Token! The turn ends.
Drizz't plays a Swamp then casts "Beast Within" on the Giant, reverting it to a 3/3 Beast Token! Then casts "Nimblewright Schematic" for two Mana, creating a 1/1 token. Ends turn.
Goblins bring out the "Great Goblin" for three Mana. For another four Mana, Equips the Sentries with the Plate Mail, giving them Menace. Attacks with the Beast (3/3), Goblins (3/2) and Sentries (3/2 -Menace). Two of the 1/1 Tokens confront the Sentries and all three die! The Jelly and the Beast kill each other! The Stony Goblin deals three points to Drizz't - he's down to 6 - and then the Jelly returns as a 1/1. Turn ends.
Still only working with five Mana, Drizz't brings out a "Death Tyrant" for all five! Ends turn.
Goblins play a Swamp. For six Mana they drop a "Desert Were-Worm"! They have three Mountains so its Power is 6! They hold and pass the turn!
Drizz't casts "Halsin, Emerald Archdruid" and then takes a knee.
The Goblins Summon a Hasted "Bolg's Company" for two Mana. Spends another five Mana to play and Equip another Crude Bent Blade on the Company. Drizz't sacrifices the 1/1. Attacks with everything! Even if Halsin blocks the Company and the Tyrant blocks the Were-Worm, there's six damage left...just enough to finish the match!
Goblins win with 19 Life left...a handy victory!
***
Postmortem: So, the Goblins had eight Land versus Drizz't's five. Also, pretty clear to see the difference between the built-in Creature type synergies versus expecting something to gel just because every card theoretically produces Tokens. Sadly, Drizz't's Token "Swarm" just isn't very "swarm-y."
***
Awrite, next match: "9" versus "8"
"Elven Council" versus "Food and Fellowship"
The Elves start first, drawing seven. They play a Forest and pass the turn.
The Hobbits start with seven and draw at the start of their turn. They play a Plains and cast "Frodo, Sauron's Bane"!
The Elves drop an Island and play "Lost Isle Calling" then pass the turn.
The Hobbits acquire a Forest and conjure up "Sting, the Glinting Dagger." Frodo then attacks for a point of damage! Turn is passed.
The Elves play a Forest and then introduce "Chance Met Elves" for three Mana. Turn passed.
The Hobbits play a Forest, table Peregrin Took and then pass the turn.
The Elves discover "The Grey Havens" which allows a Scrye, giving the Chance Met folks +1/+1 (now 4/3) and adding a Verse counter to Lost Isle Calling. They hold and pass.
Hobbits play a Forest and introduce "Butterbur" for four Mana. He then produces two Food, thanks to Pip. They hold and pass the turn.
The Elves play another Island then cast "Gift of Strands" for four Mana. This performs a two-card Scrye, giving the Chance Met crowd +1/+1 (now 5/4) and adding a Verse counter to Lost Isle Calling. Then the Strands themselves add +3/+3, so he's a whopping 8/7! They attack! Frodo chump blocks him and gets run over! End of turn.
The Hobbits play "Aragorn, Company Leader" and a "Barrow-Blade" for four Mana. They hold and pass the turn.
The Elves drop a Forest and then play "Ent's Fury" for two Mana. The Chance Met Elves are now 9/8...and get another temporary +1/+1 until end of turn! After fighting (and murdering!) Butterbur, they attack! Peregrin blocks and gets absolutely wrecked! Turn ends.
The Hobbits try to play "Eastfarthing Farmer" for three, but the Elves counter with "Glorious Gale", countering the spell! They then Equip Aragorn with a Barrow-Blade as a consolation prize and end the turn.
Elves table a Forest, play "Nimrodel Watcher" for two Manaa and then attack with the Chance Met Elves. Frodo and company take a whopping nine damage and the turn ends!
The Hobbits play a Forest and then cast "The Ring Goes South" for four Mana. Aragorn is Tempted by the Ring. They reveal only two cards: "Frodo Baggins" and "Shire Terrace", the former gets buried and the latter gets played tapped. Ends turn.
The Elves play a Forest and attack with the Chance Met Elves. Aragorn blocks and is killed. Turn ends!
The Hobbits tap four, sacrificing both Food and gaining six life! They then spend one to Sacrifice Shire Terrace, play a tapped Plains and end the turn!
The Elves play "Arwen's Gift" for four Mana. This allows a Scrye 2, giving the Chance Met crew +1/+1 (now 10/9!!!) and adding a Verse counter to Lost Isle Calling. They draw two cards, play "Fall of Gil-galad" for two which triggers a Scrye 2. This adds yet another Verse counter to Lost Isle Calling. Then the Chance Met Elves and the Nimrodel Watcher (at 3/1 thanks to the Scrye) attack. The Hobbits take 13 damage! Yikes!
Finally armed with the second Plains, the Hobbits play "Battle of Bywater", felling the Chance-Met Elves! Ends turn.
The Elves play a Forest and The Fall of Gil-galad beefs up the Watcher to 4/3! Then, in an example overkill, they play "Fangorn, Tree Shepherd" for seven Mana! The Watcher attacks, causing four damage and ending the match!
***
Postmortem: a shockingly-powerful showing by the Elves, ending with 19 Life. The Hobbits typically balloon out of control like a stuffed gut on Thanksgiving, but the Elf Scrye engine actually worked here! The Hobbits had six Mana to work with to the Elves nine and the former had to sit on Bywater Battle for far too long!
***
Next up: "18" versus "14":
"Alliance of Elves and Men" versus "Middle Earth Monsters"
The Alliance draws seven cards to start...but with only one starting Land, they mulligan and draw six cards this time. They play "Elevenking's Halls" and pass the turn.
The Monsters play "Mirkwood" and end their turn.
The Alliance plays a Forest and then tables "Bilbo, Luckwearer."
The Monsters play a Forest and introduce an "Attercop" for two Mana. Pass.
The Alliance plays "Guardian of the Halls." Bilbo attacks, causing a point of damage (19). They draw a card and discard "Great Gilded Boat" to end their turn.
The Monsters play a Forest and then "Warg Tactics" on the Attercop, making it 3/2. And, since it has Landfall, it gets boosted temporarily to a 4/3...and attacks! The Alliance lets it through, dropping them to 16.
For two Mana, the Alliance plays "Lakeshore Apothecary." Bilbo attacks, causing a point of damage (18). They draw a card and then throw out "Moment of Glory." This triggers the Apothecary, who gets a +1/+1 and goes up to 2/3. They then play "Unknown Shores" and end their turn.
The Monsters drop a Swamp but hold and end their turn.
The Alliance plays "Elven Raft-Steerer" and Bilbo attacks, causing one damage (17). They draw another card, boosting the Apothecary to 3/4! They must now discard a card, choose "Lake-town Lookout" and then end their turn.
The Monsters play a Swamp and summon a "Dreaded Bat Cloud." The Landfall-boosted Attercop gets +1/+1 and attacks! It's blocked by the Apothecary and both die! Turn ends!
The Alliance finally gets a Plains and play it, which lets the Rafter tap the Bat Cloud! They then use all four Mana to give "The Black Arrow" to Bilbo! This deals a damage to the Monsters (16). Everything attacks, causing seven damage and dropping the Monsters to 9!
For four Mana, the Monsters roll out "Mirkwood Bats" and then swoop in for four damage, down to 12.
The Alliance plays "Lake-town Lookout" and "Elvenking's Harper" for a total of three Mana. The Raft-Steerer attacks and the Mirkwood Bats block...both perish! They pass the turn.
The Monsters play a Forest and summon an "Old Fat Spider"! The Bat Cloud attacks and Bilbo blocks him...they both die! Turn ends.
The Alliance plays "The Mountain-king's Return" and discard "Thanduil's Decree." Then for one Mana, they give the Black arrow to the Guardian. They close the turn out by playing their newly-acquired Forest!
The Monsters spend two Mana for another "Attercop" and three on a "Duskwatch Hunter." The arrival of the latter gives the Old Fat Spider +1/+1...its now at an obscene 7/8. The beast attacks...and the Alliance lets them through...they're down to 5! The turn concludes.
The Alliance draws and plays an Island. "The Mountain-king's Return" adds the Raft-Steerer back to the game. For all six Mana, "Bard, King of Dale" pops in! They reluctantly hold and pass the turn.
The Monsters spend one Forest to drop in a "Mirkwood Spider." Everything attacks! Bard, the Guardian and the Rafter all block the Spider! The Spider is killed, but so is Bard and the Rafter! The Attercop (at 3/2 because of Landfall) and the Harper commit mutual murder. Finally the Lookout and the Hunter dome each other. The dead Lookout does a Recruit and the resulting non-Land card brings in a 1/1 Token. Plot twist! For two Mana, the Monsters play "Supper for Spiders" and all four Alliance fatalities become Food Tokens! To cap off this insane turn, they spend two more Mana, sacrifice an enemy corpse and gain three Life...now at 12. Ends turn.
After "The Mountain-king's Return" adds +1/+1 to the Alliance's Guardian (it's now at 4/4), it's discarded. For four Mana, they play "Silvan Reveler." The Human Soldier attacks and it's let through for one damage, putting their rival at 11, turn ends.
The Monsters tap two Mana, sacrifice an enemy corpse and gain three Life...now at 14. Holds and ends their turn.
The Alliance continues to rebuild quicker...casting "Thranduil's Company" for four Mana! Sensing a momentum shift, they attack with everything! The Spider blocks the Reveler and both die! They deliver five damage...putting the Monsters down to 9! Turn ends.
The Monsters play a Forest, tap a total of four Mana to finish off the Food! They gain six Life, back up to 15! Turn ends.
The Alliance plays an Island. The Landfall ability on the Company triggers and they goes up to 5/6! As if that's not crazy enough, the Guardian spends a whopping seven Mana and goes up by +3/+3...it's now at 7/7! Everything attacks...causing a ridiculous 13 damage, leaving their enemy with 2 Life! Passes turn.
The Monsters pull a Swamp and - with that - their hopes for a win are dashed!
***
Postmortum: Wow, this match was nuts. The Alliance ekes out a slim win with 5 Life left. Despite being Mana-choked for quite awhile, they got a lot of effective, quick creatures out and used card draw to keep their hand fresh. I though that after the slaughter and spider feast the Monsters would buy enough time to rebuild, but they got the worst possible draws. No Wolves showing us is no beuno for the Monsters.
***
Next up it's "2" and "10", so that's:
"Draconic Rage" versus "The Hosts of Mordor"
Tiamat and company only draw one Land, so they mulligan, this time drawing six cards. They table an Island and pass the turn.
Sauron draws, plays a Swamp and ends the turn.
The Dragons play a Mountain and pass.
Sauron drops a Mountain and plays "Gollum, Patient Plotter." Ends turn.
Tiamat adds another Mountain and brings out a "Lapis Orb of Dragonkind." Ends turn.
Sauron plays "Barad-dur", which comes into play untapped thanks to Gollum's "Legendary" status. They play a "Haradrim Spearmaster", which boosts Gollum's subsequent attack by +1. The Dragons take four points of damage! Passes the turn.
Tiamat casts "Breath Weapon", fries Gollum, then ends their turn!
Sauron gets another Mountain and drops an "Olog-hai Crusher" for four Mana, then attacks with the Spearmaster, causing two points of damage. Passes the turn.
After flopping a Mountain, Tiamat conjures up a "Wrathful Red Dragon" for five Mana! This allows a Scrye 2 (thanks to the Orb)...they put one drawn card on the top and the other on the bottom of the deck! Holds and passes.
A Mountain is tabled and then - for five Mana - they play "Assault on Osgiliath" which gets them a 2/2 Orc Army. They hold off attacking and pass the turn.
For five Mana, Tiamat plays a "Juvenile Mist Dragon" which taps the Haradrim Spearmaster! This allows a Scrye 2 (thanks to the Orb)...they put one drawn card on the top and the other on the bottom of the deck! The Wrathful Dragon wings over for five damage and the turn concludes.
Sauron plays a Swamp then plays "Foray of Orcs" for four Mana. The Orc Army goes up to 4/4, which then inflicts three damage on the Mist Dragon! It dies and - because of the Wrathful Red Dragon - three damage is reflected onto the Spearmaster, killing them! Both the Army and the Crusher attack, inflicting eight damage...Tiamat's down to six! Turn passes.
Tiamat plays a Forest...but holds this time!
Sauron plays "Claim the Precious" for three Mana, destroying the Dragon! The Crusher is Tempted by the Ring. Both creatures attack, ending the match! Sauron wins with 15 Life remaining!
***
Postmortem: The Dragon deck is brutal but it needs a lot more Mana flexibility. More "Evolving Wilds" perhaps? No notes for Sauron...he's quick and efficient!
***
The next random pairing is "3" pitted against "4", I.E.:
"Dungeons of Death" versus "Planar Portal"
Sefris and company play an Island, followed by a "Secret Door." Ends their turn.
Prosper draws, plays a Mountain and then ends the turn.
Sefris draws, plays "Arcane Sanctum" (tapped) and they pass.
Prosper drops a Swamp and then passes.
Sefris adds a Plains and brings out a "White Plume Adventurer." This gives them "The Initiative", so they rummage through their deck, add an Island to hand, shuffle and pass the turn.
Prosper tables a Swamp and plays "Izzet Chemister" for three Mana and passes.
Sefris draws, plays a Swamp and the Initiative lets them venture into the Undercity again. The "Forge" path adds two +1/+1 counters on the Adventurer! Then, for four Mana, they play "Shortcut Seeker." The Adventurer attacks...and Prosper lets it through, taking five damage...down to 15! Turn ends!
Prosper plays "Shadowblood Ridge" and casts "Chaos Wand" for three Mana. Ends turn.
Sefris plays a Swamp and - since they still have the Initiative - they Goad the Chemister into the Arena. where he's promptly murdered by the Adventurer! Four Mana brings out the "Veteran Dungeoneer"...allowing another Venture! They enter the Archives and draw a card! Then the Seeker and Adventurer attack...dealing seven damage. Prosper is down to 8 Life! Passes turn.
Prosper, unfortunately, doesn't pull a badly-needed Land, so they gamble with a "Share the Spoils" play. Sefris Exiles an Island, Prosper a Swamp. They play the Swamp but now must pass the turn.
Sefris plays the Exiled Island. Since they still have the Initiative, they reach the "Throne of the Dead Three" in the Undercity, draw ten (!) cards, play "Planar Ally" among them (with three +1/+1 counters on them, putting it at 6/6) and everything attacks...soundly ending the match!
***
Postmortem: just a brutal rout. Again, this came down to a poor Mana ramp for Prosper; Shadowblood Ridge was a garbage draw when you're land-starved. I think Dungeon Decks are generally regarded as a joke but this one got geared up pretty damn quick and the Undercity delivers legitimately good perks.
***
Next match: "17" versus "6"...
"Dwarves" versus "Critical Hit"!